Skip to main content
BLIPLIST

janusz_gg reviewed Minecraft

On Hold · PC · 4mo ago

I'm rating the current state of the game, which I think has drifted a long way from what made it work.

The original design had almost nothing in it and that was the point — a handful of blocks and a day-night cycle, and everything interesting came from the player. What's been added since is mostly content rather than systems: more mobs, more biomes, more decorative blocks, more structures with loot in them. Each addition is fine. Cumulatively they've turned a sandbox into a game with things to go and do, and the things to go and do are not very good.

The mob votes crystallised it for me. A community voting on which single feature gets made, annually, for a product owned by Microsoft, is a content strategy, not a development one.

Performance on the Java version is also genuinely poor for what's on screen, and has been for a decade.

A C for the current version. The 2011 version is an S and I'm aware that's an awkward position to hold.

Minecraft

2009 · Action, Simulation, Arcade

janusz_gg's radar

Tier C
janusz_gg's ratings for MinecraftStory 3.0 out of 10, Gameplay 7.0 out of 10, Graphics 6.0 out of 10, Sound 8.0 out of 10, Performance 6.0 out of 10Story 3.0Gameplay 7.0Graphics 6.0Sound 8.0Performance 6.0
Story 3.0 out of 10, Gameplay 7.0 out of 10, Graphics 6.0 out of 10, Sound 8.0 out of 10, Performance 6.0 out of 10